Back to assessments
Source assessmentContext only

Et Tu, Android? Regulating Dangerous and Dishonest Robots

Regulating dangerous and dishonest robotsAcademicdocument

Assessment outcome

total 1/4 (actionability 0 + authority 1); currency unscored, so pro-rated to 1.5/6

Total1/6
Actionability0/2
Authority1/2
Currency—

Authorship & scope

Attribution (G4 evidence)

Named author Woodrow Hartzog is clearly identified at the beginning of the article.

Issuer authority (evidence)

Level 1 (capped): the quote establishes a journal venue but does not establish the peer-review status required for Level 2.

Issuers, who it governs, legal force and content are on the full record.

Eligibility gates

G1 · Retrievablepass

HTTP 200, 8188 words of full text extracted

G2 · AI nexuspass

The source is entirely about consumer robots and their regulatory challenges.

G3 · Governance nexuspass

Discusses legal regulation, consumer protection rules, and policy implications for robots.

G4 · Attributablepass

Named author Woodrow Hartzog is clearly identified at the beginning of the article.

G5 · In forcepass

No evidence on the page indicating that this published academic journal article has been superseded or retracted.

Scored criteria

Actionability

0/2

Level 0: Description and analysis only, discussing how the FTC's existing framework applies to robots without establishing new binding obligations.

The FTC’s existing framework for protecting consumers from fraud, data breaches, privacy harms, and exploitation is robust enough to adequately protect consumers and clear enough to notify commercial entities of their obligations when designing, selling, and using robots that interact with consumers.

Authority

1/2

Level 1 (capped): the quote establishes a journal venue but does not establish the peer-review status required for Level 2.

Journal of Human-Robot Interaction, Vol. 5, No. 3, 2016, Pages 70-81, DOI 10.5898/JHRI.5.3.Hartzog Et Tu, Android? Regulating Dangerous and Dishonest Robots Woodrow Hartzog Cumberland School of Law, Samford University

Currency

—

computed: no publish/modified date found on the page (never guessed)

Classification

Coverage topicRegulating dangerous and dishonest robots
PerspectiveAcademic
Lifecycle stageN/A cross-cutting
Layerboth
Granularitydocument