Back to assessments
Source assessmentSupporting

The ethics of autonomous neurosurgical robots (ANRs)

Ethics of autonomous neurosurgical robotsAcademicdocument

Assessment outcome

total 2/4 (actionability 1 + authority 1); currency unscored, so pro-rated to 3.0/6

Total2/6
Actionability1/2
Authority1/2
Currency—

Authorship & scope

Attribution (G4 evidence)

Authored by Arturo Balaguer Townsend from the Feinberg School of Medicine, Northwestern University.

Issuer authority (evidence)

Level 1 (capped): the quote establishes a journal venue but does not establish the peer-review status required for Level 2.

Issuers, who it governs, legal force and content are on the full record.

Eligibility gates

G1 · Retrievablepass

HTTP 200, 3547 words of full text extracted

G2 · AI nexuspass

The source explicitly focuses on autonomous neurosurgical robots and algorithmic software systems.

G3 · Governance nexuspass

The source discusses the ethics, legal uncertainties, and policy implications of autonomous surgical robots.

G4 · Attributablepass

Authored by Arturo Balaguer Townsend from the Feinberg School of Medicine, Northwestern University.

G5 · In forcepass

No superseding, repeal, or withdrawal notice is present on the page.

Scored criteria

Actionability

1/2

Level 1: Provides general principles and ethical direction for stakeholders without outlining binding steps or controls.

If we do agree to develop, produce, and adopt ANRs for standard neurosurgical care, programmers must be transparent about the risks of robotic malfunction; legal experts must create clear legal solutions to the question of robotic surgical liability

Authority

1/2

Level 1 (capped): the quote establishes a journal venue but does not establish the peer-review status required for Level 2.

Bioethics published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd. This is an open access article under the terms of the http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ License

Currency

—

computed: no publish/modified date found on the page (never guessed)

Classification

Coverage topicEthics of autonomous neurosurgical robots
PerspectiveAcademic
Lifecycle stage1 Plan & design
Layermodel
Granularitydocument